← Model Answers

Paper II · 2023 · Q 8(a) · 20 Marks

“UNO was the necessity of the time when the World War II ended.” Critically examine its achievements and shortcomings.

23. The World after World War II › UNO and the global disputes

Answer:

The United Nations Organisation was founded in 1945 after the devastation of the Second World War. The failure of the League of Nations, horrors of total war, genocide, atomic weapons and need for collective security made a new international organisation necessary. The UNO has achieved much in peacekeeping, decolonisation, development and human rights, but it has also suffered from power politics, veto limitations and uneven effectiveness.

Why UNO Was a Necessity

  • The Second World War showed the catastrophic consequences of unchecked aggression.
  • The world needed an institution to prevent future wars and manage conflicts.
  • Atomic weapons made collective security even more urgent.
  • The collapse of the League of Nations highlighted the need for stronger global organisation.

Achievements of the UNO

  • The UN helped prevent direct world war between major powers after 1945.
  • UN peacekeeping missions helped manage conflicts in several regions.
  • It supported decolonisation and self-determination through trusteeship and General Assembly resolutions.
  • The Universal Declaration of Human Rights, 1948, gave moral foundation to global human rights discourse.
  • UN agencies such as WHO, UNESCO, UNICEF, FAO and UNDP contributed to health, education, children’s welfare and development.
  • The UN provided a platform for newly independent countries to raise issues of apartheid, disarmament and development.

Shortcomings of the UNO

  • The Security Council veto often paralysed action when great powers disagreed.
  • The Cold War limited the UN’s effectiveness in many conflicts.
  • The UN failed to prevent wars in Korea, Vietnam, Iraq and several regional conflicts.
  • It could not prevent genocides and humanitarian disasters in places such as Rwanda.
  • Its structure reflects the power realities of 1945 and underrepresents Africa, Latin America and parts of Asia.
  • Dependence on member states for funds and troops limits its autonomy.

Critical Assessment

The UNO is neither a world government nor a complete failure. It has worked best where great-power interests allowed cooperation and worst where great powers were directly involved. Therefore, the UNO was a historical necessity after World War II. Its achievements are significant, but its shortcomings reveal the continuing tension between global ideals and power politics.