Paper II · 2021 · Q 1(b) · 10 Marks
Tipu Sultan had little success in setting forth a course of change significantly different from the general experience of the 18th century crisis of Indian politics and society. Critically examine.
2. British Expansion in India › Tipu Sultan and eighteenth-century state
Answer:
Tipu Sultan of Mysore is often seen as an innovative moderniser; yet the claim that he transcended the general eighteenth-century crisis of Indian polity is only partly justified.
Innovations Attempted
State and economy:
- Modernised the army on European lines and sought naval power.
- State trading companies, commercial embassies (to France, Turkey), and encouragement of sericulture and industry.
- Attempts at a state-controlled economy and new revenue methods.
Diplomacy:
- Sought foreign alliances (France, Ottomans) against the English.
Continuity with the Crisis
- Rule still rested on personal, military despotism vulnerable to defeat.
- Failed to build broad social support; alienated sections of Hindus and neighbouring powers, leaving Mysore isolated.
- Revenue extraction and warfare remained central, as in other regional states.
Assessment
- His experiments were bold but did not create durable structures able to withstand British power.
Therefore, while Tipu attempted significant changes, his failure to overcome isolation and the limits of a militarised state meant he did not fundamentally break from the eighteenth-century crisis.
More from this chapter
- “The Sikh monarchy was Napoleonic in the suddenness of its rise, the brilliancy of its success and the completeness of its overthrow.”Paper II · 2025 · 10M
- “The seeds of domestic dissensions were thickly and deeply sown in the Maratha system under the Peshwas.”Paper II · 2025 · 10M
- Twenty years of peace secured by the Treaty of Salbai proved very costly to the Marathas in strategic terms. Elucidate.Paper II · 2024 · 10M
- “The Battle of Plassey (1757) was a skirmish while the Battle of Buxar (1764) was a real war.”Paper II · 2022 · 10M
- “The Treaty of Amritsar (1809) was significant for its immediate as well as potential effects.”Paper II · 2022 · 10M
- While individually the Marathas were clever and brave, they lacked the corporate spirit so essential for national independence. Discuss with reasons.Paper II · 2021 · 10M