← Model Answers

Paper II · 2023 · Q 7(a) · 20 Marks

The impact of industrial revolution on the middle class world view is reflected in the views of Adam Smith, Thomas Malthus and Jeremy Bentham. Comment.

18. Industrialization › English Industrial Revolution; Impact on Society

Answer:

The Industrial Revolution transformed Britain’s economy and society, creating a confident middle class of manufacturers, merchants, professionals and reformers. Their worldview emphasised individual enterprise, utility, discipline, market freedom and rational social order. The writings of Adam Smith, Thomas Malthus and Jeremy Bentham reflected different aspects of this emerging middle-class outlook.

Adam Smith and Economic Liberalism

  • Adam Smith’s Wealth of Nations defended free markets, division of labour and limited state interference.
  • His idea of the “invisible hand” reflected confidence in self-interest producing social benefit.
  • This suited the industrial middle class that wanted freedom from mercantilist restrictions and aristocratic privilege.
  • Smith’s emphasis on productivity and competition matched the needs of capitalist industrial growth.

Malthus and Middle-Class Anxiety

  • Thomas Malthus argued that population grew faster than food supply.
  • He warned that unchecked population growth would produce poverty, famine and misery.
  • His ideas reflected middle-class fears of pauperism, working-class growth and pressure on resources.
  • Malthusian thought influenced attitudes towards poor relief and discipline of the labouring classes.

Bentham and Utilitarian Rationalism

  • Jeremy Bentham proposed the principle of “greatest happiness of the greatest number”.
  • He favoured legal reform, administrative efficiency and rational calculation of utility.
  • His thought reflected the middle-class desire to reform old institutions on rational and practical lines.
  • Utilitarianism influenced law, education, prisons, poor law and colonial governance.

Shared Middle-Class World View

  • All three thinkers reflected faith in reason, order and improvement.
  • Smith represented economic freedom; Malthus represented social discipline; Bentham represented rational reform.
  • Together they expressed the ideological needs of industrial capitalism.

Critical Assessment

However, this worldview often ignored the harsh experiences of workers: low wages, long hours, child labour and urban misery. E.P. Thompson highlighted the making of the working class as a painful social process. Therefore, the views of Smith, Malthus and Bentham reflected the intellectual world of the industrial middle class: confident, rational and reformist, but also limited by class interests.