← Model Answers

Paper I · 2017 · Q 2(a) · 15 Marks

Art and culture are reflected to a far greater extent than political history in the epigraphic sources. Comment.

1. Sources › Inscriptions

Answer:

Inscriptions are the most reliable of early Indian sources, being contemporary, dated and immune to later interpolation. Yet their content is uneven: because most were issued to record gifts, endowments and pious acts, they illuminate art, religion and social life far more fully than they narrate political events.

Why cultural information predominates

  • The overwhelming majority are donative records of gifts to temples, monasteries and Brahmanas.
  • They name deities, festivals, rituals and sects, mapping religious life in detail.
  • They record the building of temples, tanks, wells and images, dating monuments precisely.
  • They name sculptors, architects and guilds, illuminating the organisation of art.
  • Language, script and literary style within them chart cultural change over centuries.

Illustrative examples

  • The Besnagar pillar of Heliodorus attests early Greek devotion to Vasudeva.
  • Nasik and Karle cave inscriptions record guild endowments for Buddhist establishments.
  • The Aihole inscription of Pulakeshin II is as much a literary composition as a record.
  • Chola inscriptions at Uttaramerur describe village assemblies and temple administration.

The political information they do carry

  • Prashastis such as the Allahabad pillar of Samudragupta narrate conquests and genealogy.
  • The Junagadh inscription of Rudradaman records both public works and military success.
  • Ashokan edicts convey imperial policy directly in the ruler's own voice.
  • Land grants preserve dynastic succession and the titles of rulers.

The limits of the political record

  • Prashastis are panegyric, magnifying victories and passing over defeats in silence.
  • They rarely supply chronology, administrative structure or the causes of events.
  • Wars, successions and reverses go largely unrecorded.
  • D.C. Sircar cautioned that eulogy must be discounted before such records are used.

Types of epigraphic evidence

  • Ashokan edicts on rock and pillar are the earliest deciphered Indian inscriptions.
  • Copper-plate charters record land grants with boundaries, privileges and witnesses.
  • Temple wall inscriptions, especially Chola, record endowments and administration in detail.
  • Hero-stones and sati-stones commemorate individual deaths.
  • James Prinsep's decipherment of Brahmi in 1837 opened the whole corpus to historians.

The comment is therefore well-founded. As epigraphists such as D.C. Sircar emphasised, the purpose for which inscriptions were issued determines what they preserve, so they give us an unrivalled picture of religion, art and society while offering only a partial and flattering glimpse of political history.