← Model Answers

Paper II · 2020 · Q 5(e) · 10 Marks

"The British were slated to withdraw from Palestine in May 1948, and both sides prepared for that day. Violence between Arabs and Jews, already endemic, escalated." Critically examine.

West Asia and the Arab-Israeli Conflict › Middle East

Answer:

As the British mandate over Palestine neared its end in May 1948, the long-simmering conflict between Arabs and Jews escalated sharply into open war, for both communities prepared for a decisive struggle over the land that a weary Britain was abandoning after decades of failed mediation.

Background to the crisis

  • Decades of Jewish immigration, encouraged by the Balfour Declaration of 1917, had produced deep Arab-Jewish tension.
  • Britain, unable to reconcile the two communities, finally referred the problem to the United Nations.
  • The UN partition plan of 1947 was accepted by the Jews but firmly rejected by the Arabs.

Escalation and its outcome

  • Communal violence intensified as the mandate's end approached, with attacks on both sides.
  • The State of Israel was proclaimed on 14 May 1948 as Britain withdrew.
  • The first Arab-Israeli war followed at once, leaving Israel enlarged and creating the Palestinian refugee problem.

The roots of British failure

  • Britain had made incompatible promises to Arabs, Jews and the French during the First World War.
  • The White Paper of 1939 restricted Jewish immigration, angering the Zionists.
  • The Holocaust intensified international pressure for a Jewish homeland after 1945.
  • Jewish paramilitary groups and Arab resistance made the mandate ungovernable.
  • Exhausted and near bankruptcy, Britain chose withdrawal over a settlement.

The statement thus accurately captures the escalation of 1948: the impending British withdrawal turned endemic violence into open war. As historians note, Britain's departure left an unresolved conflict whose eruption into the first Arab-Israeli war set the pattern of a struggle that continues to this day.