← Model Answers

Paper II · 2020 · Q 5(b) · 10 Marks

"The causes of the French Revolution of 1789 included both long term and structural factors, as well as more immediate events." Critically examine.

The French Revolution › French Revolution

Answer:

The French Revolution of 1789 sprang from a combination of long-term structural weaknesses in the old order and immediate short-term crises, so that deep-seated grievances and a precipitating financial and subsistence emergency together produced the great upheaval of that year.

Long-term structural causes

  • The rigid society of orders privileged the clergy and nobility while burdening the Third Estate.
  • An inefficient, absolutist state and an unjust, exemption-ridden tax system bred deep resentment.
  • Enlightenment ideas of liberty, equality and popular sovereignty undermined the old order's legitimacy.
  • A rising and ambitious bourgeoisie chafed at its exclusion from power and privilege.

Immediate causes

  • A severe financial crisis, worsened by war debts, brought the monarchy to the edge of bankruptcy.
  • Bad harvests in 1788 caused soaring bread prices and popular hunger.
  • The calling of the Estates-General in 1789 provided the decisive political spark.

From crisis to revolution

  • The Third Estate's demand for voting by head led to the Tennis Court Oath of June 1789.
  • The fall of the Bastille on 14 July turned political deadlock into popular revolution.
  • The Great Fear in the countryside forced the abolition of feudal privileges in August.
  • The Declaration of the Rights of Man proclaimed the Revolution's guiding principles.
  • Lefebvre showed how aristocratic, bourgeois, urban and peasant revolts converged.

The statement is therefore well-founded: the Revolution was the product of both long-term structural factors and immediate triggers. As historians emphasise, the deep grievances of the Third Estate needed the financial and subsistence crisis of the late 1780s to ignite them into open revolution.