← Model Answers

Paper II · 2024 · Q 1(b) · 10 Marks

The values of utilitarianism prompted the Company administration to attempt reform of Indian society.

3. Early Structure of the British Raj › The English utilitarian and India

Answer:

In the early 19th century, Company rule in India came under the influence of utilitarianism, especially the ideas of Jeremy Bentham and James Mill. Utilitarians believed that laws and institutions should promote the “greatest happiness of the greatest number.” This outlook encouraged the Company administration to attempt reforms in law, education and society.

Utilitarian Influence on Reform

Rational and legal reform:

  • Utilitarians criticised Indian society as backward, traditional and governed by irrational customs.
  • They wanted codified laws, uniform administration and rational governance.
  • This influenced legal reforms and later codification under figures like Macaulay.

Social reform:

  • Utilitarian ideas supported intervention against practices considered harmful or irrational.
  • The abolition of sati in 1829 under Bentinck reflected humanitarian, utilitarian and evangelical influences.
  • Measures against thuggee and support for female education also reflected reformist thinking.

Education policy:

  • Utilitarians supported Western education as a means of producing rational and useful subjects.
  • Macaulay’s Minute of 1835 promoted English education and Western knowledge.
  • Education was seen as an instrument of social transformation.

Limits of Utilitarian Reform

Colonial interest:

  • Reform was not purely humanitarian.
  • It also aimed to create a more efficient colonial administration and loyal educated class.
  • The Company was cautious when reforms threatened political stability.

Other influences:

  • Evangelical Christianity, Orientalist scholarship and Indian reformers also shaped reform.
  • Raja Rammohan Roy’s role in the anti-sati movement shows that Indian agency was important.

Therefore, utilitarian values did influence Company reform by promoting rational law, social intervention and Western education. However, reform was shaped by a combination of utilitarian thought, evangelical pressure, colonial administrative needs and Indian reformist initiatives.